A rate $600 higher than the market will bear. Such a shame. I have been told that if an insurance company has a customer with no claims they become profitable within about three years. Based on this it is safe to say a customer of 62 years has earned your company some money, yet you let them go. Kind of like the goofy T.V. or movie scenario where the employee of 30 years gets a cheap watch and a certificate of appreciation.
In your own world be sure that loyalty goes both ways. Loyalty is earned and should not be given. If you vote with your dollars you will likely not have this happen to you.
Leave the pen and pencil set behind, you can buy plenty more with your savings.